===== PAGE 1 ===== ## FDOT FPID 441524-1-32-01 ## Northbound Tamiami Trail (US 41) Vision Study from William Street to Peace River Bridge Public Involvement Activities Summary ===== PAGE 2 ===== ## Public Involvement Activities – Summary Extensive public involvement was performed as part of the Northbound Tamiami Trail (US 41) Vision Study to better understand the vision of the community and existing issues along the corridor.
Image
Image
Image
US41
Image
===== PAGE 3 ===== ## Public Involvement Activities – Summary • Weekly meetings with City staff • Meetings with Officials • Presentations to MPO Committees & Board • Stakeholder Meetings – Chambers & Economic Development Partnership • 6 Stakeholder Focus Groups – 18 organizations/21 participants • Individual Stakeholder Discussions – 14 organizations *SEE TABLE ON NEXT SLIDE FOR SPECIFIC MEETING DATES
Image
- City social media platforms • Email Blasts/Ad • Newsletter Website Comment Forms (via website or email) – 20+ comments received Questionnaire – 255 responses with 180 comments received Public Involvement Tools
Image
===== PAGE 4 ===== ## Public Involvement Activities – List of Meetings
Meeting DateMeeting Participant(s)
2/17/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
2/25/2021Charlotte County-Punta Gorda MPO Bicycle Pedestrian Advisory Committee
3/3/2021Charlotte County-Punta Gorda MPO Citizens Advisory Committee
3/3/2021Charlotte County-Punta Gorda MPO Technical Advisory Committee
3/9/2021Punta Gorda City Council Member Prafke
3/10/2021Punta Gorda Mayor Matthews
3/11/2021Punta Gorda City Council Member Miller
3/16/2021Charlotte County Commissioner Constance
3/18/2021Punta Gorda City Council Member Cummings
3/18/2021Punta Gorda Vice Mayor Carey
3/19/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
3/22/2021Charlotte County-Punta Gorda MPO Board
3/26/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
3/31/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
MPO = Metropolitan Planning Organization ===== PAGE 5 ===== ## Public Involvement Activities – List of Meetings (continued)
Meeting DateMeeting Participant(s)
4/7/2021Charlotte County Chamber of Commerce
4/9/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
4/12/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
4/14/2021Charlotte County Economic Development Partnership
4/16/2021Punta Gorda Chamber of Commerce
4/20/2021Punta Gorda City Staff and Charlotte County-Punta Gorda MPO Staff
4/23/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
4/28/2021Charlotte County-Punta Gorda MPO Citizens Advisory Committee
4/28/2021Charlotte County-Punta Gorda MPO Technical Advisory Committee
4/30/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
5/5/2021Punta Gorda City Staff (Lane Repurposing District Review Team Kickoff Meeting)
5/10/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
5/18/2021Stakeholder Focus Group A (Establishments near Carmalita St & Olympia Ave)
5/19/2021Stakeholder Focus Group B (Hotels/Businesses north of Marion Ave)
MPO = Metropolitan Planning Organization ===== PAGE 6 ===== ## Public Involvement Activities – List of Meetings (continued)
Meeting DateMeeting Participant(s)
5/20/2021Stakeholder Focus Group C (Bike/Transit/Freight)
5/21/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
5/24/2021Stakeholder Focus Group D (Traditionally Underserved/Under Represented)
5/24/2021Stakeholder Focus Group E (Religious Centers)
5/27/2021Stakeholder Focus Group F (Homeowner Associations)
6/4/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
6/8/2021Sacred Heart Catholic Church
6/8/2021Deep Creek Community Church
6/10/2021Cheney Brothers
6/10/2021Charlotte County Office of Emergency Management
6/10/2021The Wyvern Hotel
6/11/2021Verizon
6/11/2021Four Points by Sheraton Punta Gorda Harborside
6/11/2021Charlotte County Transportation Disadvantaged Local Coordinating Board
===== PAGE 7 ===== ## Public Involvement Activities – List of Meetings (continued)
Meeting DateMeeting Participant(s)
6/11/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
6/17/2021Charlotte County-Punta Gorda MPO Bicycle Pedestrian Advisory Committee
6/18/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
6/18/2021Chase Bank
6/21/2021Punta Gorda City Council Member Prafke
6/22/2021Cross Trails Center/Benderson Development
6/22/2021Punta Gorda Vice Mayor Carey
6/22/2021Punta Gorda City Council Member Miller
6/23/2021Punta Gorda Mayor Matthews
6/23/2021Punta Gorda City Council Member Cummings
6/25/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
6/25/2021TEAM Punta Gorda/Share the Lane Punta Gorda
6/28/2021Gulf Coast Partnership
6/30/2021Charlotte County-Punta Gorda MPO Citizens Advisory Committee
===== PAGE 8 ===== ## Public Involvement Activities – List of Meetings (continued)
Meeting DateMeeting Participant(s)
6/30/2021Charlotte County-Punta Gorda MPO Technical Advisory Committee
7/2/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
7/9/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
7/12/2021Sacred Heart Catholic Church/Diocese of Venice
7/14/2021Punta Gorda City Council
7/15/2021Punta Gorda Fire Department
7/16/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
7/19/2021Charlotte County-Punta Gorda MPO Board
7/23/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
8/12/2021Starbucks
8/13/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
8/27/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
9/17/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
9/24/2021Punta Gorda City Staff
MPO = Metropolitan Planning Organization ===== PAGE 9 ===== ## Public Involvement Activities – Results Top Comments • Inconsistent travel speeds/signal re-timing • Lane changing/lane designations • Aggressive driving – turn lanes used as raceways • Wrong way driving • Better connect Downtown across US 41 • Better accommodate visitor traffic – enhanced pedestrian and bicycle facilities • Separate spaces for pedestrians, bicycles, & vehicles • Traffic calming • In favor of traffic signal at Retta Esplanade • Roundabout education • No parking on US 41
Image
Image
===== PAGE 10 ===== ## Stakeholder Focus Groups
Image
Image
===== PAGE 11 ===== ## Stakeholder Focus Groups The following 6 Stakeholder Focus Groups were held: • Group A (Establishments near Carmalita St & Olympia Ave): 5/18/2021 • Group B (Hotels/Businesses north of Marion Ave): 5/19/2021 • Group C (Bike/Transit/Freight): 5/20/2021 • Group D (Traditionally Underserved/Under Represented): 5/24/2021 • Group E (Religious Centers): 5/24/2021 • Group F (Homeowner Associations): 5/27/2021
Image
Image
===== PAGE 12 ===== ## Stakeholder Focus Group A Establishments near Carmalita St & Olympia Ave Establishments Invited To Participate: • Cross Trails Center • Chase Bank • Marathon Gas Station/The Famous Corner Store • Verizon • Sacred Heart Catholic Church • Punta Gorda Chocolate & Wine/Punta Gorda Coffee & Tea • Gregg's Automotive Maintenance & Repair Center • Sandra's - Array of Cabinets - McCrory Law Firm - CAM Realty
Image
Image
Landsberg Bennett Private Wealth Management ===== PAGE 13 ===== ## Stakeholder Focus Group A – Comments Received traffic calming ## PRIORITIES dedicated turn lanes
Image
prohibit wrong way driving better (on US 41 and Olympia). Wrong way signs. consistent travel times fix "raceway" near bridge and keep access to 4 Points consistent travel times - slow through downtown
Image
## DOWNTOWN VISION / VIBE pedestrian friendly
Image
better connect downtown across US 41 tourists can cause issues spur economic development in downtown. Specifically vacant land. setup well for parades. rich in history easier to walk from hotels to downtown destinations. better signage. busy during events current lack of safe ped. facilities consider redevelopment of City Marketplace. lane changing ## GENERAL CONCERNS & ISSUES aggressive driving incident on bridge slows US 41. No good alternate routes. Happens in reverse if crash on I-75. Changing number of through lanes causes additional issues. Better dynamic signing would help. inconsistent travel speeds PG Chamber will have input pedestrian bridges Carmalita Street the left lane north of Retta Esplanade
PROBLEM LOCATIONS
pedestrian access north of Marion Ave fix crashes at Olympia due to lane drop Taylor - setup is fine. No trouble tough to turn left approaching bridge from east side Olympia is an issue. blind corner near PGI/Cubbies ## POTENTIAL IMPROVEMENTS Lane Designations signal re-timing dedicated alternative use lanes wrong way signs traffic cameras dynamic messaging signs on-street only combination of on-street parking & parking garages ## PARKING see how Lexington, KY has done it as an example Not enough streets to accommodate all parking needs. Events center or Justice Center are options for parking garage. Lack of parking is currently an issue. Will be worse if City marketplace is developed additional parking garage. Must be walkable to downtown. ===== PAGE 14 ===== ## Stakeholder Focus Group B Hotels/Businesses north of Marion Ave Hotels/Businesses Invited To Participate: • Four Points by Sheraton Punta Gorda Harborside • Springhill Suites by Marriott Punta Gorda Harborside • The Wyvern Hotel • Dean's South of the Border • Charlotte Harbor Event and Conference Center • Smugglers Group • Blue Turtle & FM Dons • Perfect Caper • Celtic Ray
Image
Image
===== PAGE 15 ===== ## Stakeholder Focus Group B – Comments Received ## GENERAL CONCERNS / ISSUES / PROBLEM LOCATIONS lane changing inconsistent travel speeds Carmalita Street aggressive driving the left lane north of Retta Esplanade Tough to get east of US 41 during lunch and other busy times - walking and driving Lack of crosswalk at Harborside. Long distance between Marion and Harborwalk. pedestrian access north of Marion Ave Long wait to turn north from Harborside. Can be dangerous too. Retta Esplanade - signal would help traffic calming
POTENTIAL IMPROVEMENTS / PRIORITIES
Image
dedicated turn lanes Lane Designations signal re-timing dedicated alternative use lanes Lane drop north of Harborside should be fixed if possible. "Speedway" is dangerous. on-street only ## PARKING combination of on-street parking & parking garages consistent travel times Volume may be too high for parking Parking would be a bigger issue if City Marketplace is developed ## OTHER keep consistent landscaping and lights through City Roundabout at Carmalita makes sense ===== PAGE 16 ===== ## Stakeholder Focus Group C Bike/Transit/Freight Entities Invited To Participate: - TEAM Punta Gorda/Share the Lane Punta Gorda • Charlotte County-Punta Gorda MPO Bicycle and Pedestrian Advisory Committee (Chair & Vice Chair) • Peace River Riders • Coastal Cruisers • Charlotte County Transit Division • Charlotte County Public Schools Transportation • Cheney Brothers Florida Department of Transportation District One Freight
Image
Image
• Charlotte County Office of Emergency Management FDOT ===== PAGE 17 ===== ## Stakeholder Focus Group C – Comments Received ## GENERAL CONCERNS / ISSUES / PROBLEM LOCATIONS lane changing inconsistent travel speeds Carmalita Street aggressive driving the left lane north of Retta Esplanade pedestrian access north of Marion Ave lack of lane continuity north of Taylor separate bridge for bikes/peds conflicts for bikes north of Taylor lane drop near Four Seasons is a big issue Aqui Esta left turn issues for bikes - off project limits traffic calming Lane Designations ## POTENTIAL IMPROVEMENTS / PRIORITIES dedicated turn lanes signal re-timing Lower speed limit may reduce through traffic. dedicated alternative use lanes no issue with cycletrack if there is room. Good for high traffic area. consistent travel times Any garages will need to be near downtown Add bike lanes north of Airport Rd - off project limits. combination of on-street parking & parking garages Use Cooper St as alternate route around downtown. on-street only ## PARKING
Image
lack of parking currently in downtown ## OTHER mountable curbs for trucks freight deliveries will remain even if not a major through corridor - most traffic generators are further south ===== PAGE 18 ===== ## Stakeholder Focus Group D Traditionally Underserved/Under Represented Entities Invited To Participate: • Charlotte County Transportation Disadvantaged Local Coordinating Board • Volunteers of America • Punta Gorda Housing Authority • The Salvation Army Family Store • New Operation Cooper Street, Inc. Bethel AME • First Macedonia Church • St. Mary Primitive Baptist • Meals on Wheels • Habitat for Humanity • Charlotte County Human Services Department • Charlotte County Community Development Department
Image
Charlotte County Community Services Department
Image
===== PAGE 19 ===== ## Stakeholder Focus Group D – Comments Received ## GENERAL CONCERNS / ISSUES / PROBLEM LOCATIONS lane changing Carmalita Street inconsistent travel speeds aggressive driving the left lane north of Retta Esplanade Account for ADA improvements/access for surrounding populations (age, underserved) pedestrian access north of Marion Ave Turning out of Wyvern - issue drag race north of Retta Esplanade - pulling out to go North- dangerous design for Taylor Road and other projects - incorporate crossing Carmalita at US 41 - issue 170,000 platted lots - master planned communities - this stretch of city is a bottleneck - 3-2 lanes Elder Demographic population - pulling around slower drivers leads to aggressive driving & inconsistent travel speeds Safety improvements for school kids - buses use corridor & cross Carmalita - talk to School Board Bridge is constrained too - better accommodate multimodal aspects in future benefit to keep things as is - slower speeds/congestion - regulates speed next time bridge project - paint bike lane green - examples in Lee & Collier slower traffic makes it more walkable neighborhoods east of US 41 NB are underserved - increase access across roadway by foot/bike traffic calming Lane Designations signal re-timing dedicated turn lanes ## POTENTIAL IMPROVEMENTS / PRIORITIES dedicated alternative use lanes May want to look at parallel facilities for other bike/ped facilities - better linkage to other streets downtown - enhance access to other facilities across US 41 Teeth to policies & enforcement - traffic cameras Phase I: strengthen existing crossings; Phase II - additional Sunseeker proposing garage - not sure if public - intent for parking and walking in downtown Carmalita is priority crossing Parking doesn't affect County consistent travel times Parking hasn't been an issue Consider scooters/micro-mobility modes in design Accommodate for visitors - heavy bike/ped traffic On-street parking could be an issue on US 41 due to demographics How to account for human nature - enforcement needs to be a priority for improvements to be beneficial combination of on-street parking & parking garages on-street only ## PARKING Event Center uses parking on Taylor & vacant area - once vacant area gets developed - could cause an issue - walking several blocks not appealing to population of area & given weather - may need another garage ## OTHER HAWK signals - may be appropriate at vacant lot, Retta Esplanade, Carmalita, Taylor/W Charlotte Crossing W Charlotte and US 41 - dangerous for pedestrians ===== PAGE 20 ===== ## Stakeholder Focus Group E Religious Centers Religious Centers Invited To Participate: • Church of the Good Shepherd • Church of the Nazarene • Deep Creek Community Church • First Baptist Church Punta Gorda • First United Methodist Church
Image
• Peace River Baptist Church • Punta Gorda Seventh Church • Souls Harbor Church of God
Image
===== PAGE 21 ===== ## Stakeholder Focus Group E – Comments Received No Religious Centers Attended/Participated
Image
Image
===== PAGE 22 ===== ## Stakeholder Focus Group F Homeowner Associations Homeowner Associations Invited To Participate: • Burnt Store Isles Association Inc. • Punta Gorda Isles Civic Association • Historic Punta Gorda Civic Association • Realtors Association • Private Citizen
Image
Image
===== PAGE 23 ===== ## Stakeholder Focus Group F – Comments Received ## GENERAL CONCERNS / ISSUES / PROBLEM LOCATIONS lane changing inconsistent travel speeds Carmalita Street aggressive driving Traffic signal is great at Retta Esplanade - lots of pedestrian traffic pedestrian access north of Marion Ave White lines on road - pedestrians took as crosswalks - need signal SB on US 41 at Retta Esplanade - make uniform for pedestrians crossing both NB & SB US 41 at Retta Esplanade Wrong way driving - need better signage or pavement markings - Carmalita roundabout may help too Look at Edgewater roundabout - may help with Get rid of free flow lane at Taylor - get rid of pavement on east side - left turn only at Olympia - left turn only at Retta - eliminate merging at bridge demographic issues regarding roundabout use Elderly population may have difficulty with roundabout Speeding is problem-keep traffic flow at reasonable speed - drag stip to NB bridge Multi-lane roundabouts - could increase accidents - creates confusion - need to educate - need to have correct markings for proper use Pedestrians have hard time crossing at roundabouts traffic calming Lane Designations signal re-timing dedicated turn lanes Landscaping - looks nice - be careful regarding tree size dedicated alternative use lanes ## POTENTIAL IMPROVEMENTS / PRIORITIES Lane designations are important - Orlando is example - improved traffic & confusion Left lane to bridge - PLEASE FIX! Signal timing coordination - could increase speed - get traffic through at reasonable pace while balancing bike/pedestrian safety Address pedestrian crossings/flow across US 41 at Retta Esplanade - especially with visitors in area due to hotels, event center, waterfront, & restaurants Brick pedestrian crossings at Midway look nice - maybe consider as accents since brick/cobblestone can be problematic/not as safe for scooters/folks with disabilities Balance between ADA compliant & aesthetic treatments on-street only combination of on-street parking & parking garages ## PARKING Keep on-street parking off US 41 - can cause accidents & slow traffic flow Parking garages offer much more space Adequate parking now - might have to walk a bit more - might not be as close as you want - might not last with growth/ should be proactive in addressing parking solutions There might be a garage built at event center Widening of US 41 through Downtown? - FDOT may look at converting 1-way pair to 2-way ## OTHER Like scramble crosswalks ITS would be helpful Traffic study done for Sunseekers? - need to accommodate visitors from airport to US 41 Countdown at signals for pedestrians/motorists - helpful 2045 LRTP identifies new bridge to east of existing bridge - additional bridge to US 41 bridge - could be "new" US 41 bridge - look at Fort Myers I-75 bridge as example ===== PAGE 24 ===== ## Questionnaire Results
Image
Image
===== PAGE 25 ===== ## Questionnaire Results High Scores from Questionnaire ## PRIORITYES: • Consistent Travel Time • Dedicated Turn Lanes • Enhanced Lane Markings
Priorities
Image
• Pedestrian – Enhanced Sidewalk ## IMPROVEMENTS: - Bicycle – Shared Use Path
Pedestrian Improvements
Image
Bicycle Improvements
Image
===== PAGE 26 ===== ## Questionnaire Results Low Scores from Questionnaire ## PRIORITYES: On-Street Parking • Resurface Road Only
Priorities
## IMPROVEMENTS: Pedestrian Existing Sidewalk • Curb Extension
Image
Diagonal Crosswalk Bicycle • Separated Bike Lanes
Pedestrian Improvements
- Bike Lane/Shared Use Path Together
Image
Bicycle Improvements
Image
===== PAGE 27 ===== ## Questionnaire Results • Ranking of Study Priorities (a lower number represents a higher priority ranking):
Image
## Consistent Travel Time
Image
## Bicycle Facilities
Image
Image
## Dedicated Turn Lanes
Image
## Traffic Calming
Image
• Consistent Travel Time – 2.63 ## Average Priority Rankings: • Bicycle Facilities – 2.76 • Dedicated Turn Lanes – 2.76 • Traffic Calming – 2.84 ===== PAGE 28 ===== ## Questionnaire Results • Ranking of Study Priorities (a lower number represents a higher priority ranking):
Image
## Resurface Road Only
Image
## Pedestrian Facilities
Image
## Enhanced Lane Marki
Image
Image
## OnStreet Parking
Image
## Average Priority Rankings: • Resurfacing Road Only – 2.84 • Pedestrian Facilities – 2.94 • Enhanced Lane Markings – 2.99 • On Street Parking – 3.80 ===== PAGE 29 ===== ## Questionnaire Results • Pedestrian Features Rankings (a higher number represents a greater preference for feature):
Image
Existing Sidewalk
Image
Times rated: 161 Average rating: 2.453
Curb Extension
Image
Times rated: 199 Average rating: 2.618
Diagonal Crosswalk
Image
Shared Use Path
Image
Image
Times rated: 162 Average rating: 3.586
Enhanced Sidewalk
Image
• Enhanced Sidewalk – 3.95 ## Average Priority Rankings: Times rated: 169 Average rating: 3.947 FDOT • Shared Use Path – 3.59 • Diagonal Crosswalk – 2.70 • Curb Extension – 2.62 • Existing Sidewalk – 2.45 ===== PAGE 30 ===== ## Questionnaire Results Bicycle Features Rankings (a higher number represents a greater preference for feature):
Image
2Way Separated Bi...
Image
Times rated: 151 Average rating: 2.146
Bike Lane Shared U...
Image
Times rated: 159 Average rating: 2.296 1 Way Separated Bi...
Image
Times rated: 161 Average rating: 2.422
Buffered Bike Lane
Image
Times rated: 193 Average rating: 3.083
Shared Use Path
Image
Image
Times rated: 168 Average rating: 3.595 • Shared Use Path – 3.60 • Buffered Bike Lane – 3.10 ## Average Priority Rankings: • 1-Way Separated Bike Lanes – 2.42 - Bike Lane-Shared Use Path – 2.30 • 2-Way Separated Bike Lanes – 2.15 ===== PAGE 31 ===== ## Contact ## Richard (OJ) Oujevolk Project Development Manager, Environmental Management Florida Department of Transportation 863-519-2293 Richard.Oujevolk@dot.state.fl.us
Image