{
    "document_id": 12451,
    "page": 6,
    "width_pt": 612,
    "height_pt": 792,
    "rotation": 0,
    "pipeline_version": "paddleocr-vl-1.6+paul-48",
    "engine": "paddleocr_vl",
    "source_run_id": 12562,
    "item_count": 9,
    "counts_by_type": {
        "text": 9
    },
    "build_ms": 2,
    "items": [
        {
            "id": "p6.1",
            "order": 1,
            "type": "text",
            "bbox": {
                "l": 68.88,
                "t": 719.76,
                "r": 535.2,
                "b": 691.2
            },
            "text": "She wanted to voice her concerns with the use on this property and they seem to be always be pushing boundaries. She feels this will affect taxes, going from two lots to one."
        },
        {
            "id": "p6.2",
            "order": 2,
            "type": "text",
            "bbox": {
                "l": 69.36,
                "t": 683.04,
                "r": 427.2,
                "b": 669.36
            },
            "text": "M s. Bradley said this is a land use Board and they cannot consider tax concerns"
        },
        {
            "id": "p6.3",
            "order": 3,
            "type": "text",
            "bbox": {
                "l": 69.6,
                "t": 660.72,
                "r": 168.48,
                "b": 647.52
            },
            "text": "Public Session Closed"
        },
        {
            "id": "p6.4",
            "order": 4,
            "type": "text",
            "bbox": {
                "l": 68.88,
                "t": 637.44,
                "r": 541.92,
                "b": 551.76
            },
            "text": "M s. Jennings said she believes the Board understands what they are seeking tonight and just depends on how they vote. Whether the second house is an accessory and or did they satisfy the positive negative criteria for the D variance. Dr. Hofstein asked how far over the property line is the new proposed pool. Mr. Back said the new pool is almost entirely over the existing property line. Mr. M atins wants to know if they are paying separate taxes. Ms. Cipriani said when they consolidate it will be one lot."
        },
        {
            "id": "p6.5",
            "order": 5,
            "type": "text",
            "bbox": {
                "l": 68.64,
                "t": 543.36,
                "r": 539.52,
                "b": 353.52
            },
            "text": "M s. Cipriani reminded the Board the initial request is on the interpretation, whether the existing home on Pitney house qualifies as an accessory structure. The definition was read into the record from the township code. There is consolidation into one lot. The land use standard is that when a Board is asked to determine when a proposed use as an accessory use, it is important to examine analytically the nature of accessory uses to determine whether they are in fact accessory in nature, if associated with use on the same factor of land or determine whether they would be permitted independently on a tract of land where no other use exists to which the use in question could be considered an accessory. (Cited in Cox law for accessory use) M s. Cipriani said the Pitney house is currently permitted on a tract of land with no other uses and has been a single family home for 30 years. There was testimony for consolidation on the lots. There is case law, Urban vs Planning Board, it was determination that the beach houses never functioned independently that they had always been accessory structures. It is M s. Cipriani's recommendation that it is not an accessory structure. The applicants' planner testified, in connection with township code, that an accessory is incidental and subordinate to the principal use."
        },
        {
            "id": "p6.6",
            "order": 6,
            "type": "text",
            "bbox": {
                "l": 68.4,
                "t": 346.56,
                "r": 543.84,
                "b": 201.36
            },
            "text": "M r. Heiman, does not see it as incidental without possibly removing the kitchen and the fact that it has a separate driveway. M r. Silecchia said if the driveway on Pitney was eliminated or closed off he is struggling with calling it an accessory use. M r. M artins agreed and is struggling with imposing restrictions, and if they can be enforced. M s. Jennings advised the applicant would be willing to close off the driveway but is not willing to remove the kitchen. M s. Rosal said removing the driveway helps consider it as an accessory, along with the combined utilities. Dr. Hofstein does not see how it can be considered an accessory building. M s. Bradley said she is struggling with seeing it as accessory, it is a standalone home. M r. Tremer said with fully functioning kitchen it is a standalone house. M r. Heiman is not concerned with the applicant being there while his house is under construction and it would be temporary use."
        },
        {
            "id": "p6.7",
            "order": 7,
            "type": "text",
            "bbox": {
                "l": 69.36,
                "t": 193.44,
                "r": 369.36,
                "b": 179.76
            },
            "text": "M s. Bradley advised Yes vote will be that it is not an accessory use"
        },
        {
            "id": "p6.8",
            "order": 8,
            "type": "text",
            "bbox": {
                "l": 69.36,
                "t": 171.6,
                "r": 520.08,
                "b": 128.16
            },
            "text": "Motion / Bradley Second / Hofstein Yes Vote: Heiman, Martins, Tremer, Hofstein, Bradley\nNo Vote: Rosal feels it could be accessory with the combination of utilities and removal of driveway,\nCusano agrees with Rosal"
        },
        {
            "id": "p6.9",
            "order": 9,
            "type": "text",
            "bbox": {
                "l": 69.36,
                "t": 119.76,
                "r": 348.48,
                "b": 105.84
            },
            "text": "It is Boards interpretation that it is not an accessory structure"
        }
    ],
    "excluded_furniture": {
        "first": [],
        "last": []
    }
}